What is education?
EDUCATION Education has several advantages to the people concerned and to society as a giant.
The health effects of education will be giant and therefore the education of ladies will considerably
cut back kid mortality rates. However, education charities are unlikely to be as value effective as
another intervention. Education charities in developing countries generally aim to extend the time
that kids pay in educational establishments and therefore the quality of teaching that the kids receive
by building faculties, tutoring outside the schoolroom, rising skill, incentivizing attending, and
provide provides and technology. during this class we have a tendency to embody primary,
secondary,
and tertiary, education, however not vocational education or health-specific education, like teaching
regarding HIV and hygiene. the majority of them on the market analysis covers primary education
and this page reflects that. sorts of Education Interventions (Much of this list originated on
GiveWell's Education Page ). This list is split into supply-side (providing provides, buildings or
teacher training) and demand-side (helping to inspire faculty attendance) interventions. Supply-Side
Interventions faculty building: building lecture rooms or buildings for government-run faculties, and
build and run faculties themselves. Teacher coaching: training new academics and upgrade the
talents
of established academics. Pre-primary faculties: running faculty for kids ages 3-6 to arrange them for
school. Textbooks and supplies: providing textbooks, and everything from pencils to chalkboards to
uniforms and shoes. Computers: funding pcs in lecture rooms in faculties and supply free computer
coaching categories. Libraries: building school- and community-based libraries. Tutoring: providing
centered facilitate for college students WHO are behind their peers. Example from J-PAL. Demand-
Side Interventions Scholarships: sponsoring individual students and fund faculties in order that
students don't have to be compelled to pay the college fees that are common within the developing
world. attending Incentives: rising or providing faculty bathrooms, or offer free meals in school,
rising health and inspiring attending. Motivating Parents: explaining the economic advantages of
getting their kids educated so as to create education a priority for the family. we have a tendency to
don't apprehend of any charities that perform this intervention however we have a tendency to
believe
it to be extremely effective. (See here for a study conducted in Madagascar.) Ensuring that children
are healthy enough to attend school: addressing the health-related reasons why children do not attend
school. Often simple health interventions such as deworming or providing micronutrients will
increase the time spent in school. This is highly effective. Demand-side interventions are generally
considered more effective. With demand-side interventions, the money is only spent if the
intervention is working, for example, free school meals to motivate kids going to school will only
cost money if the kids are actually going to the school and eating the meals. On the other hand,
supply-side interventions have large upfront costs, are more complicated to implement, and often do
not work, for example, you may build a school and no students will attend, or you will provide books
and they will not be used. Potential Benefits Education interventions promise a wide range of
potential benefits: increased economic growth; higher rates of societal production; quicker adoption
of technological change; development of government and business leaders; improved health;
empowering women; and the intrinsic value of education. There is a strong correlation between
education and wages in later life. One additional year in school for an individual has been shown to
increase wages later in life by about 10 percent. However, this does not necessarily mean an increase
in total wages of the country, as a more educated person may simply displace someone less educated.
This could be the case if a country does not have institutions that facilitate new businesses which can
absorb better-educated workers, causing workers to compete over a fixed number of 'good jobs'.
There are also significant health benefits to education. Simply attending a school can encourage use
of health services later in life. Education also empowers women and may let them have more control
over health decisions that affect themselves and their children and reduces future infant mortality
rates .rates.Effectiveness In order to know whether to invest in an educational intervention, we need
to have some way of comparing them to other interventions - in particular to health interventions and
our recommended charities. We used the DALY measurement to evaluate health interventions. The
most common way of measuring education interventions is 'number of test score standard deviations
gained'. There is, however, no straightforward way of converting the multiple effects of better
education into averted DALYs, and any decision about which is preferably between health
intervention and education interventions (or between any two types of interventions with different
effects) will be based on a number of assumptions and approximations. Intuitively, it seems very
likely that providing better education, textbooks, skilled teachers, and classrooms will improve the
lives and potential outcomes for children living in developing countries. However, most programs
measure exactly those (number of schools built, number of books provided, number of computers
donated, etc.), and do not provide comparable statistics on improved literacy, health outcomes, and
future income increases. Providing textbooks may not work without training teachers, and building
schools may not help if the children don't attend due to sickness, and even a well-educated child may
have no opportunity if presented with unfavorable economic and social conditions. There are many
reasons why an education intervention may fail and that providing basics of nutrition and economic
assistance may be initially required for an educational intervention's subsequent success.
Unfortunately, cross-country comparisons suggest that education is not necessarily associated with
higher income per capita. If this is correct, education may not increase average wages. This is a
surprising result, but it should at least give us pause to question how effective education actually is.
In developing countries, education can be valued more as a way of selecting employees than as a
measure of knowledge, particularly when education is of low quality. The students who stay longer
in
school and get better test scores will be offered better jobs, displacing those with lower scores.
Another possible explanation is that education has received so much funding and development over
the last 50 years that the economic benefits to further improving education are minimal. The growth
in education enrollment is - in many African countries - an order of magnitude higher than the
growth
of wage employment. developing countries are now educating enough people (to primary level) to
fill
the jobs that required educated people. Another possibility is that the quality of schooling is so poor
that spending time there isn't providing students with valuable work skills. There are exceptions. For
example, in India, when Green Revolution technologies were coming into play, education had a big
positive effect on average wages, as the educated rural workers were able to adapt to using the new
technologies much faster than less educated workers. In comparison, there is evidence that health
interventions can have significant positive economic effects. For example, by comparing areas with
different levels of malaria we can see that areas with less Malaria have more economic growth. One
study estimated that eradicating malaria in an area will give a 3% increase in household expenditure.
Research on deworming has found even larger returns, though there are fewer primary studies to rely
on. Some have suggested that education has intrinsic value, even above any improvements in health
or material quality of life it might generate. The World Values Survey, the largest collection of data
on correlates of well-being, suggests that years in education does not itself increase happiness. By
contrast, health itself was found to have a significant effect on an individual's welfare. As mentioned
above, there are significant health improvements resulting from better education. Often these health
effects are hard to measure because it is difficult to control for the more educated people getting
better jobs so living healthier. The greatest health effect is the reduction of infant mortality rates for
the next generation. For instance, one year of extra education for women can lead to a reduction in
infant mortality rates by 5-10 percent, and five extra years of education for women in Africa can
reduce infant mortality by up to 40 percent. A lower infant mortality rate reduces the fertility rate,
and so reduces the chance of a woman dying during childbirth. It has also been estimated that
education can reduce the chance of a mother's death from about five percent to about 1.4 percent.
Encouraging education may be an effective health intervention. Increasing the secondary and
tertiary
education of a population can entice multinational corporations, particularly as technology allows for
cross-border employment, creating new domestic positions that require educated people, so may
have
an overall positive effect economically. Giving What We Can have not yet looked at the effects of
interventions that increase the secondary and tertiary education. Conclusions Many "common sense"
education interventions, such as programs providing books and educational material and building
schools, are minimally effective. There is a general lack of consistency in results and scalability.
Interventions that work well in one area may very well fail in another. We have not yet come across
any clear evidence that suggests that future charitable spending on education interventions will have
more than a small economic effect in the majority of cases, especially compared to the economic
effects of health interventions. It is also possible that health improvements, reducing child mortality
rates and more, that result from better education are highly cost-effective and that encouraging
education may be an effective health intervention. Giving What We Can look further into this
possibility.
Tuesday, January 15, 2019
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 comments:
Post a Comment